Barokko's bit is getting a little worn by the rings, so I'm looking to exchange it before there are any sharp edges that could bother him. He doesn't seem
super comfortable in this bit, so I'm considering if I should get a different type.
I've tried a few different bits on him, and he reacts very differently to each of them. He's worn a single jointed loose ring, double jointed loose ring (2 different thicknesses), double jointed 2-ring elevator bit (trail rides only), soft hackamore (trail rides only), and a French link Boucher.
Out of these, I've deduced (by amount of resistance to the bit both on the ground and under saddle, soft chewing vs irritated chomping, head tossing etc) that this is how he'd rank these bits:
1. Thin double jointed
2. Thick double jointed
3. Single jointed
4. Boucher
5. Elevator
I'm not sure where to place the hackamore, I've never actually ridden dressage in it, only on trails, and by far most of the time on a loose rein. It's not competition legal, so it isn't a bit I've considered using for regular training. On the few occasions that I asked for a bit of contact he did take it willingly and fairly steadily, and seemed comfortable in it. Maybe I should test it in the arena one day, just to see what it feels like to ride with connection in it.
The elevator I've only used on trails, and with 2 reins. I used the lower rein a few times when he grabbed the bit and ran through my aids, just to check his acceleration, and then rode off the snaffle rein the rest of the time. He got very upset when I used the lower rein, tossing his head and chomping on the bit. I thought his irritation might be because I stopped his naughty behaviour, so I carefully tried to see how he reacted to me riding him off the lower rein in a relaxed, controlled situation, and he still reacted very negatively to it. I got the subtle message that he doesn't like the way it feels, and have only used it a few times.
I had hoped the Boucher would be a good fit for him, but he gets very tense if I ride him in it and resists
any rein aid, also from the ground.
Dressage riders here are
very conservative when it comes to bits. Snaffle bits are either single or double jointed loose rings, that's about it. You might occasionally run into an eggbutt snaffle, but that's only the very adventurous riders who would dare try something so unconventional ;)
The following snaffles are competition legal:
- Single jointed loose-ring
- Double jointed loose-ring (center joint must be rounded)
- Eggbutt snaffle (single or double jointed)
- Single jointed D ring
- Single jointed Full Cheek
- Single or double jointed Fulmer
- Single jointed half cheek
- Single jointed Boucher
- Unjointed snaffle - mullen mouth and eggbutt versions also allowed
- Snaffle bits with rotating mouthpiece
- Single jointed rubber snaffle
- Unjointed rubber snaffle
But no-one takes advantage of the range of options. This also means that the only dressage legal bits that tack stores bother to stock are the standard single and double jointed loose rings.
I'm thinking it would be interesting to see Barokko's reaction to a Mullen mouth bit, or a
Myler Comfort snaffle - but neither are readily available :/ We're going to the US this summer, so I could buy a few different bits there, but I don't really want to wait several months. So I guess it's online shopping, here I come!
ETA: I ordererd the two bits from a British online tack store, an eggbutt mullen mouth and a Myler Comfort wide barrel loose ring snaffle. Both bits that are quiet in the mouth and with no nutcracker effect. I hope he'll take a liking to one of them!